When Students Lead the Discussion

When Students Lead the Discussion



few years ago, my colleague Brenda Whitney spoke at a workshop about how class discussion can take on many different forms, each with its own style and descriptive moniker. Paraphrasing and borrowing language from her handout, with a few revisions of my own, these discussion styles include:

  • The Tennis Match – teacher and student lob questions and responses back and forth, with the rest of the class as spectators.
  • The Whirlpool – participants circle around a subject, moving slowly toward a deeper penetration of it.
  • The Eclectic Beaded Necklace – students contribute independently, sequentially, without much interconnection.
  • The Tour Bus – travels from destination to destination, with passengers trusting the tour guide to explain each point of interest.
  • Urban Sprawl – a discussion that begins with a tight center but soon spreads unchecked to uncharted and unpredictable locations.
  • The Life Raft – everyone is drowning in either a difficult text or in difficult questions, so that when one answer is offered up, the class grabs on for dear life and won’t let go of that idea for fear of getting swept to sea.

A teacher at the seminar, Sam Hamilton, added another one: the Wild West Train, where the conductor must get his precious cargo to the train station, despite efforts by bandits to derail and rob the train.

And if I might add one to the list, I’ve noticed that this quarter my class has become a Spoked Wheel: each student is a spoke, each spoke never touches the others, and my job as the hub is to connect the spokes. This is my doing, an effort to move away from the Eclectic Beaded Necklace (which I easily fall into) toward a conversation where each contribution connects to the others. But I now want to find an alternative to the Spoked Wheel, a way for students to talk to each other, to not rely on me to hold together our conversations. I’d rather the class discussion be a Construction Crew Without a Foreman, that is, a crew that works toward a goal, together building something that each member could not have built individually—but they do this on their own, without oversight.

We had just read Gloria Anzaldúa’s “How to Tame a Wild Tongue.” I asked the students to circle up, get out the Anzaldúa essay, and then to do a bit of writing. First, they had to go to a passage they found provocative and write a paragraph about what draws them to that specific part of the essay. Second, they had to write three discussion questions based on the passage and their response to it. After 10 minutes of writing, I told the class we had 15 passages with 15 responses and 45 possible discussion questions. That’s a lot of material. So, I said I would not be talking for the next 10 minutes. I explained that the class would run the discussion, and I would grab my notebook and pencil, take a seat in the circle, and listen. Which is exactly what I did.

The students looked at each other and back at me. Narelle was the first to speak. “What do you think Anzaldúa means by copping out?” The class was confused. They did not have a context for Narelle’s question, a passage to work with, or a sense of what prompted the question. Narelle picked up on this. She elaborated, mentioning the part of the essay that provoked her question and explaining why she thinks the question matters. Still, the class needed more. “What page are you on?” Molly asked. Narelle responded. Gabrielle asked, “Can you read us the passage?”

This—two minutes into my silent period—was the pivotal moment in the discussion. The class began to do the work I normally do, setting up the context for a discussion question, pointing us toward the text and reading from it. Zaq offered an answer to Narelle, a response Jillian then paraphrased: “So, you’re saying that …” Ten minutes into the discussion (the point I had said I would start speaking) I was hearing phrases like “To go back to your question …” and “Going back to what Max said, that connects to what Narelle asked.” The students were synthesizing their comments. When Laura said, “I agree, because when I lived in Italy…,” she was making a “yes, and …” move, placing her own story against and among the comments from her classmates and then building upon what they’d said. Even though I had follow-up questions to ask, even though I wanted to comment on—and correct—a few things they’d said, even though I wanted to press against how they were reading Anzaldúa, I stayed silent. It would have been foolish to interrupt.

Remaining silent
Twenty minutes in, Ella voiced resistance to Anzaldúa: “I have a problem with this essay. It makes me mad.” Max elaborated: “The part that bothered me was” and here, he went to the text, reading aloud for his classmates. They’d moved from questions clarifying Anzaldúa’s claims to synthesis to now, late in the conversation, their responses to the essay. This surprised me. I expected them to begin with their responses and take their time getting into the argument itself. They did the inverse, making their way through Anzaldúa’s essay while incorporating comments from across the classroom, reading aloud from the text, paying close attention to the way Anzaldúa’s words fall on the page, the conversation building to Ethiopia’s question, a question I was going to ask had I led the discussion: “If you have multiple languages, how do you know what you really are?”

I’ve tried not speaking in class once before, about five years ago, and it failed miserably. Perhaps it worked this time because I tried it midway through the term, once the students knew each other and each other’s names, once the students had established a classroom rapport. Perhaps it worked this time because the students wrote in preparation for the discussion. Perhaps it worked this time because they all had something to say in response to Anzaldúa. Perhaps it worked this time because I’d been more deliberate since the first day of class to splice together their comments during class discussion, modeling the synthesis I’d hoped they would eventually do on their own.

But questions linger. That the students talked so well on their own, that they did not need me to salvage the discussion, that I was not the hub holding together the conversation, has me wondering when I should speak in class and when I should remain silent. I think about how often I could attempt the teacher-less discussion and what pedagogical purpose it might serve at various points in the course. I think, too, about what teacher-less teaching might look like in other contexts—a teacher-less essay assignment, a teacher-less reading list, a teacher-less syllabus—and what preparation would need to happen to make these teacher-less efforts both pedagogically sound and productive. And I think most about the teacher-student relationship, about how much of a presence I should have in my students’ learning, and at what point (and how) I should step back, giving them space to work, to read and write, to stumble and fail and succeed on their own. My silence that afternoon leaves me uncertain what teaching looks like—which is a good place for a teacher to be.

Anzaldúa, Gloria. “How to Tame a Wild Tongue.” Borderlands / La Frontera: The New Mestiza. San Francisco: Aunt Lute Books, 2012. 4th ed. 75-86.

Written by.

Article from:

When Students Lead the Discussion


  1. Pingback: essayforme

  2. Pingback: Cialis tablets australia

  3. Pingback: Viagra generico online

  4. Pingback: Cialis 20mg prix en pharmacie

  5. Pingback: Viagra tablets

  6. Pingback: Cialis online

  7. Pingback: Cialis generic

  8. Pingback: Viagra generico

  9. Pingback: Cialis 20mg prix en pharmacie

  10. Pingback: Cialis 20mg

  11. Pingback: Cialis 20mg

  12. Pingback: Cialis 5 mg

  13. Pingback: Cialis coupon

  14. Pingback: Cialis 5 mg

  15. Pingback: Generic cialis

  16. Pingback: where to buy cialis online

  17. Pingback: tedwap.me

  18. Pingback: click here

  19. Pingback: tube

  20. Pingback: Cialis 20mg

  21. Pingback: tadalafil 40 mg

  22. Pingback: cialis pills

  23. Pingback: cialis pills for sale

  24. Pingback: cialis tablets australia

  25. Pingback: cost cialis 20mg

  26. Pingback: generic cialis 20mg

  27. Pingback: generic cialis available

  28. Pingback: generic cialis tadalafil

  29. Pingback: generic cialis tadalafil uk

  30. Pingback: tadalafil generic

  31. Pingback: tadalafil generic best price

  32. Pingback: tadalafil without a doctor prescription

  33. Pingback: cialis generic

  34. Pingback: cialis generic name

  35. Pingback: cialis generic availability

  36. Pingback: cialis generic availability 2018

  37. Pingback: cialis generic prices

  38. Pingback: cialis generic tadalafil

  39. Pingback: cialis generic pharmacy

  40. Pingback: levitra generic

  41. Pingback: sildenafil citrate

  42. Pingback: levofloxacin 750 mg

  43. Pingback: viagra 100mg

  44. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg

  45. Pingback: azithromycin 250 mg

  46. Pingback: augmentin 875 mg

  47. Pingback: amiodarone 200 mg

  48. Pingback: lipitor generic

  49. Pingback: simvastatin 20 mg

  50. Pingback: best price for viagra

  51. Pingback: diflucan 150 mg

  52. Pingback: levitra 20 mg

  53. Pingback: viagra pills

  54. Pingback: cialis 20mg tablets prices

  55. Pingback: levitra 20mg best price

  56. Pingback: biaxin generic

  57. Pingback: biaxin antibiotic

  58. Pingback: cost of biaxin antibiotic

  59. Pingback: biaxin coupon

  60. Pingback: biaxin coupons

  61. Pingback: fluoxetine hcl

  62. Pingback: fluoxetine 20 mg

  63. Pingback: prozac generic

  64. Pingback: prozac medication

  65. Pingback: fluoxetine 10 mg

  66. Pingback: alprostadil

  67. Pingback: alprostadil price

  68. Pingback: buy cialis

  69. Pingback: cialis oral jelly

  70. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg coupon

  71. Pingback: buy viagra

  72. Pingback: cialis

  73. Pingback: viagra

  74. Pingback: cialis coupon

  75. Pingback: cialis 20mg

  76. Pingback: levitra

  77. Pingback: generic cialis

  78. Pingback: cialis online

  79. Pingback: tadalafil 5mg

  80. Pingback: tadalafil 20mg

  81. Pingback: viagra tablets

  82. Pingback: sildenafil

  83. Pingback: tadalafil

  84. Pingback: cialis dosage

  85. Pingback: cialis prices

  86. Pingback: cialis tablets

  87. Pingback: viagra vs cialis

  88. Pingback: generic viagra

  89. Pingback: viagra connect

  90. Pingback: viagra without doctor prescription

  91. Pingback: viagra natural

  92. Pingback: cialis vs viagra

  93. Pingback: tadalafil 20 mg

  94. Pingback: cialis 20 mg

  95. Pingback: cheap cialis

  96. Pingback: cialis coupons

  97. Pingback: cialis canada

  98. Pingback: viagra online

  99. Pingback: viagra prices

  100. Pingback: viagra generic

  101. Pingback: generic viagra 100mg

  102. Pingback: viagra coupons

  103. Pingback: cheap viagra

  104. Pingback: generic viagra available

  105. Pingback: buy viagra online

  106. Pingback: viagra tablet

  107. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg

  108. Pingback: sildenafil 100

  109. Pingback: buy biaxin

  110. Pingback: buy ceftin

  111. Pingback: buy chloromycetin

  112. Pingback: buy biaxin online

  113. Pingback: buy ceftin online

  114. Pingback: chloromycetin

  115. Pingback: buy cordarone

  116. Pingback: cialis 20mg generic

  117. Pingback: female viagra

  118. Pingback: sildenafil tablets

  119. Pingback: prednisone 20 mg

  120. Pingback: buy sildenafil

  121. Pingback: sildenafil generic

  122. Pingback: viagra doctor prescription

  123. Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg

  124. Pingback: sildenafil coupons

  125. Pingback: sildenafil 100 mg

  126. Pingback: sildenafil citrate 100mg

  127. Pingback: buy cialis online

  128. Pingback: cialis tadalafil

  129. Pingback: sildenafil citrate tablets

  130. Pingback: sildenafil citrate pricing

  131. Pingback: bactrim ds

  132. Pingback: ceftin antibiotic

  133. Pingback: cephalexin 500mg

  134. Pingback: ciprofloxacin 500mg

  135. Pingback: fluconazole 150 mg

  136. Pingback: levofloxacin 500 mg

  137. Pingback: we-b-tv.com

  138. Pingback: hs;br

  139. Pingback: tureckie_serialy_na_russkom_jazyke

  140. Pingback: tureckie_serialy

  141. Pingback: 00-tv.com

  142. Pingback: +1+

  143. Pingback: æóêè+2+ñåðèÿ

  144. Pingback: Ñìîòðåòü ñåðèàëû îíëàéí âñå ñåðèè ïîäðÿä

  145. Pingback: Ñìîòðåòü âñå ñåðèè ïîäðÿä

  146. Pingback: watch

  147. Pingback: ++++++

  148. Pingback: HD-720

  149. Pingback: guardians+of+the+galaxy+2

  150. Pingback: strong woman do bong soon

  151. Pingback: my id is gangnam beauty

  152. Pingback: 2020

  153. Pingback: kpop+star+season+6+ep+9

  154. Pingback: Video

  155. Pingback: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

  156. Pingback: wwin-tv.com

  157. Pingback: movies

  158. Pingback: movies online

  159. Pingback: karan johar

  160. Pingback: Top Movies

  161. Pingback: Movies1

  162. Pingback: 11 10 2019

  163. Pingback: smotretonline2015.ru

  164. Pingback: Serial smotret

  165. Pingback: kinokrad

  166. Pingback: kinokrad 2020

  167. Pingback: ñïèñîê íîâûõ ôèëüìîâ

Comments are closed